Basic Five-Part Structure of
Written Arguments*
1. Introduce the topic, or question-at-issue/problem,
and establish its importance.
-
Show its significance to society.
-
Use description, explanation, narrative to describe issue/problem.
-
Choose a primary strategy of appeal: emotional, logical,
ethical.
2. Provide necessary background information
so that
readers will be able to follow
your discussion.
-
History of the issue/problem?
-
Specific example of issue/problem; effect on individuals;
narrative?
3. State your claim (your argumentative thesis,
or solution to problem) and develop your argument, making a logical appeal
based on the following factors:
-
Generalization
-
Causation
-
Analogy
-
Parallel case
-
Authority (experts).
4. Support your claims with facts, opinions,
examples. If appropriate, stir in emotional or ethical appeals,
but never rely on them.
-
Acknowledge counter arguments and treat them with respect.
Give opposing voices their due by quality paraphrase/summary, then refute
these arguments. Reject their evidence or their logic, and/or concede some
validity and refute accordingly.
-
After counter arguments and refutations have been addressed,
move on to your own claims.
-
The core of argument/counter argument, concession/refutation
must fill the middle of the essay and be appropriately introduced
and concluded.
5. Conclude by summarizing the main points of
your argument, and/or rephrase the benefits of your solution to the
key problem, and tell the reader what you want them to do!
*Based on information contained in Discovery and Commitment,
by Leonard J.
Rosen.
|